NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WKRN) — The 23-year-old man suspected of fatally stabbing two young men outside of a Midtown bar over the weekend has been captured.
Metro police said Michael Mosley surrendered from a vacant home on Petway Road in Cheatham County Wednesday afternoon, December 25, after it was surrounded by law enforcement. He was there alone, officers revealed.
Mosley had been added to the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation’s “Most Wanted” list early Tuesday morning. He was wanted on two counts of criminal homicide and one count of attempted criminal homicide in connection with a deadly stabbing outside the Dogwood Nashville on Division Street.
According to Metro police, Mosley stabbed three people outside of the bar around 3 a.m. Saturday. Two of the victims, Clayton Beathard, 22, and Paul Trapeni, III, 21, did not survive their injuries. A third man, A.J. Bethurum, suffered wounds to his arm and eye, but was expected to recover.
One victim, Clayton Beathard, was the younger brother of San Francisco 49ers player C.J. Beathard; their father is a songwriter for top country musicians; their grandfather Bobby Beathard was an NFL executive.
Police explained the incident began when Mosley made “an unwanted advancement” toward a female friend of the victims inside the bar. The three victims reportedly intervened to help the woman and were later stabbed outside.
At the time of the fatal stabbing, investigators said Mosley was free on a $5,000 bond after attacking a 37-year-old woman at the Walmart on Charlotte Pike in December 2018.
Mosley, who has an extensive criminal history in Nashville and Cheatham County, will be held without bond in the Metro jail on two counts of criminal homicide and one count of attempted criminal homicide.